@ Cunego - Sorry mate thought i answered your question. You asked -
'Bear, i think i have asked you this 2 times before but il try again, do you agree that shoving dont remove skill?'.........
It depends on the situation which was what I was trying to say. if you perma shuv like 90% of the time then of course it removes skill as their is almost no post flop play where someone can out manoever you or force you to fold. An excellent example of such a style of play is covered by a well know player called Rolf Slotboom who talks about short stack play. He basically states it is amlost unbeatable by skillful players as it eliminates post flop play/skill. If you have only so many blinds and are comitting either pre flop or on the flop how can someone outplay you ?? Simply put they can't. This well know Pro demonstrates this strategy excellently in several of his books and openly admits it eliminates a lot of hard decisions post flop. As such it requires LESS SKILL to play this way and he openly admits it is an excellent way to play against a MORE SKILLFULL player............
So in summary pre flop shuvn is part of the game mate i totally agree. It is part of the skill requirements so i agree with you on this point. Where i disagree is that it should not be 80% of your game when you have more than 10 BB in play. You may say its a matter of style and that is a fair comment but when you have 14/15 BB I don't believe that should be auto shuv territory and I do believe there is room to play poker post flop.
Hope that explains a little better of where i am coming from mate...........